umineko when they cry question update backgrounds

It seems someone messed around with that. The Higurashi games used to each have their own page. Klashikari ( talk) 15:56, 7 February 2009 (UTC) Reply There must be some proper order behind structuring the description of each character, but the way you did is really inconsistent (and I think a discussion would have been better instead of removing portions like this, all of a sudden). For instance, I do not see why you removed sakutarou, but left Gaap mention, despite it is a 'spoiler' that yet Beatrice has another demon furniture. While I do believe some things must be done against some spoiler-ish information, you are arbitrarly filtering the information on your own.

Even mere explanations such like the siblings' money issues or Maria seemly 'bipolar' personality might sound a spoilers for some people. The problem is also the fine line between appropriate content and spoilers, which is why there is absolutely no rule regarding 'spoilers' on Wikipedia. Rather the whole cast has its own page, while the root page had a digest summary of the main characters. Higurashi no Naku Koro ni does not have any individual page for the games. WhiteKnightLeo ( talk) 12:59, 7 February 2009 (UTC) Reply People will come to the article where there weren't spoilers before and have the games completely ruined for them in a heartbeat. There are no spoilers for the other games, so it should be left that way. There is no reason to include her in the character list and spoil her identity as well. For example, the short-haired Beatrice who only appeared in Episode 3. The spoilers mainly consist of info that is over-excessive and not relevant to more than one game. Rather, it should be done like the Higurashi page, with spoilers left to articles focusing on the individual games. I request spoilers stop being posted on the main page. Klashikari ( talk) 10:00, 2 February 2008 (UTC) Reply Right you are I've removed the bits about them being siblings.- 十八 10:42, 2 February 2008 (UTC) Reply Satan In any case, I think it would be rather logical to remove the sibling information in the article. Yet again, various lines in the visual novel states 'kanon loved her as a sister'.

I believe it would be better to leave it to person interpretation. Klashikari ( talk) 22:06, 1 February 2008 (UTC) Reply Any speculation would be considered original research and would not be able to be included.- 十八 00:00, 2 February 2008 (UTC) Reply Indeed, that's why I pointed that issue, as there isn't any solid confirmation that these 2 characters are really siblings. The fact Shannon commented that 'he just consider me as a older sister' and the explanations behind the servants of the Fukunon House are kinda pointing to the non blood relative status. Can we really extrapole they are siblings?Ĭonsidering their origins as orphans explained in episode 1, it might be a simple 'sibling like' relationship, but absolutely not blood relative wise.

Umineko when they cry question update backgrounds